I need to send a card back to my client before their next recording session. They sent me an SD card with 53 voice clips to clean up for an exhibit. I copied the clips to my work drive and checked them, but when I put the card back in, my computer said it needed to be formatted.
If the files are safe, do you usually reformat the card and keep using it, or replace it? What makes you choose?
Do not format the card. Make two copies of the data onto another drive, and return the card (in a envelope/packet marked up to show that you should not record on it, just format it), leaving it as it is.
If you want to narrow down what happened, the reader check in the cleverfiles sd card repair guide makes sense here. Try the card in a different reader and decline any format prompt. The prompt alone doesn’t prove the card is failing, but a successful reformat wouldn’t tell you why it happened either.
For the session, I’d send a replacement that the client’s recorder supports and ask them to format it in the recorder, record a short clip, and play it back before anyone sits down. That’s what decides it for me: you’ve protected the last session’s audio, but the next take won’t have a backup when they hit record.
Do not place the edited clips onto the replacement card. If the client has formatted the card for the next session they may accidentally erase your work. Send an empty card and provide the exhibit recording separately.
We would leave the original card intact. Only attempt to recover from a corrupt card in the event that the client mentions that a recording is missing. Make a copy of the card and perform the recovery on this. As we have confirmed that all recordings are present, we do not want to delay the despatch of the media by attempting to fix any issues.
Do not reuse the card (even if you are able to repair the problem). However, sending a replacement may be useful as testing a copy may reveal file system corruption even if all clips play correctly.
If there will be a delay in returning the card, then we will simply send them a new/ repaired card. We should not hold up the next session waiting for this card.
Do they have any spares? If so we can test with this. If not, we can find out what model of recorder they have so we can get a suitable card from locally, if it is very urgent.
Please return the original card as is. We do not need to spend time getting it working if we would not advise them to record onto it.
If there was an issue with the card in the recorder and the client sent it back, we should provide them with a replacement card. However, if the issue was shown in the form of a formatting message on the client’s PC, we should just provide a replacement card and not the recorder. We should also ask whoever performed the previous session what, if anything, appeared on the screen of the recorder.
Why the difference?
If after replacing the card, we still cannot get the device to work (the new card is supported by the recorder) we should swap the recorder. It may be helpful to do a short test recording and playback, however, it may be good to inform the client what to do in case of failure.
We should return the card in its original state. On returning the card we should include a note which states “Audio was successfully copied from the card. When inserting the card again, the pc prompted me to re-format the card.” This tells the client we are providing them with a new card but does not tell them that their card did not work with the recorder.