What's the best photo culling software?

I’ve just come back from a long trip and took thousands of photos. Now, I’m overwhelmed and need to sort out the best ones quickly. Which photo culling software do you recommend for this task? Your suggestions would be much appreciated!

For culling thousands of travel photos, I would highly recommend trying out Adobe Lightroom’s culling features. Lightroom has been a staple in photo management for years, and it’s packed with powerful tools to help you sort, rate, and organize your images quickly.

What I particularly like about Lightroom is the ability to use the star rating system and color labels to mark the best shots immediately. You can also use Lightroom’s smart previews to speed up the process if you have a large catalog, as it allows you to work with smaller file sizes without sacrificing too much quality.

Another excellent option to consider is Photo Mechanic. This software is incredibly fast and designed specifically for photo culling. Photo Mechanic allows you to quickly go through the images and rate them, which you can then import into more comprehensive editing software like Lightroom or Photoshop.

On one of my long trips, I took about 5,000 photos and felt completely overwhelmed just like you. I found that using Photo Mechanic drastically cut down the time I spent on culling, and it integrated seamlessly with my existing workflow in Lightroom.

If you’re after something more AI-driven, you might want to check out Narrative Select. It’s a newer entrant to the market, but it’s gaining traction for its intelligent culling features. Narrative Select uses machine learning to help you identify the best images by detecting blinks, focus issues, and other technical flaws.

Ultimately, the best software will depend on your personal preferences and workflow, but Lightroom, Photo Mechanic, and Narrative Select are all strong contenders. If you’re already in the Adobe ecosystem, Lightroom might be your best bet, but for sheer speed, Photo Mechanic is unparalleled. Give them a try and see which one feels right for you.

Considering the sheer volume of photos you mentioned, Adobe Lightroom and Photo Mechanic certainly stand out for their robust organization and sorting capabilities. However, if you’re looking for another angle, I’d suggest giving FastRawViewer a shot. It’s incredibly efficient for those who shoot RAW photos, offering real-time histogram displays and exposure statistics, which is great for quick and informed decision-making.

One particular feature I appreciate about FastRawViewer is its high performance with large file sizes and its ability to render RAW files quickly without lag. This can be a lifesaver if you’re toiling through thousands of images. FastRawViewer allows you to zoom in and check fine details without delays, and you can assign ratings that can be exported to other programs like Lightroom later.

Another tool worth mentioning is AfterShoot. This AI-driven software aims to make culling faster by automatically selecting the sharpest images and filtering out the rejects. Though slightly less established than Lightroom or Photo Mechanic, it’s gaining popularity due to its smart culling capabilities. This might save you considerable time, especially with the advanced tech improvements it brings to the table.

If you’re open to exploring, ON1 Photo RAW also offers a speedy culling process. It incorporates features similar to Lightroom but with a more straightforward, less cluttered interface. It includes AI-driven tools that can help you accelerate the process of sorting and flagging your best shots and integrates well into existing workflows.

While Lightroom is excellent for its comprehensive suite, and Photo Mechanic impresses with its speed, these alternatives like FastRawViewer, AfterShoot, and ON1 Photo RAW might provide the nuanced advantage you need. Keep in mind, too, that sometimes, simple software like FastStone Image Viewer can do wonders—it’s free and fast for bulk viewing and basic management.

Ultimately, FastRawViewer merits a closer look given its nimble performance with RAW files and efficiency that matches your need for a rapid culling process. If you couple it with another tool like Lightroom for post-processing, you might find a winning combination that streamlines your workflow effectively.

I think, beyond what’s already been mentioned, you might want to give Exposure X7 a try as well. This software does not only focus on culling but also adds a lot of value in terms of advanced photo editing. One compelling aspect is its non-destructive workflow, allowing unlimited undo and redo steps—a lifesaver if you’re uncertain about some of your culls.

Now, @suenodelbosque highlighted Adobe Lightroom, and that’s an undeniably robust choice, but one thing to note is that it can be quite heavy on system resources, especially if your computer isn’t top-tier. This can slow down your culling process significantly if you’re handling thousands of photos.

As for @vrijheidsvogel’s recommendation of FastRawViewer, it is indeed excellent for RAW files, but it can feel somewhat limited if you’re planning to do detailed edits beyond basic culling. Plus, the interface might not be as intuitive for some users, especially if you’re coming from more user-friendly platforms.

Exposure X7, on the other hand, also offers presets and a very user-friendly interface that feels modern, less cluttered. It’s more than just a culling tool and lends itself to quite efficient post-production work too.

Pros for Exposure X7:

  1. Non-destructive workflow: No risk in culling decisions.
  2. Advanced editing capabilities: Beyond just culling, strong editing tools.
  3. Presets and customizable workspace: Efficient and adaptable according to needs.

Cons for Exposure X7:

  1. Learning curve: Might take some time to get used to if unfamiliar.
  2. System requirements: Still needs a decently powerful computer.

All things considered, it might be worth giving Exposure X7 a try, especially if you’re also aiming to streamline your entire photo editing process. Don’t discount other options like @vrijheidsvogel’s FastRawViewer and @suenodelbosque’s lightroom, but it seems vital to find what meshes with your specific needs and workflow.